The New York Federal Appeals Court has allowed Christian Louboutin to protect it’s red sole trademark.
Over the last several months the French shoe brand has been involved in a hefty legal battle with Yves Saint Laurent’s production of a red soled shoe from the 2011 resort collection.
August 2011 saw a federal judge deny Louboutin’s pleas to stop all sales of the YSL shoe stating that ‘Louboutin is unlikely to be able to prove that its red outsole brand is entitled to trademark protection’.
However, it seems that Louboutin having lost the battle has won the war (mostly), as an appeals court has overturned the previous decision and has ruled that Louboutin can protect his trademark red soles, the only exception to this ruling is when the shoe itself is red.
Business Week reports that the appeals judges wrote, “The District Court’s conclusion that a single colour can never serve as a trademark in the fashion industry was based on an incorrect understanding of the doctrine of aesthetic functionality and was therefore in error”.
It’s a partial victory for the shoe brand, as the lawsuit brought against Yves Saint Laurent involved a pair of red suede shoes with red soles making these shoes exempt from the the new trademark ruling. However, the ruling is still significant as it sends out a strong message to any other company who had any thoughts of selling red-soled shoes in the future.























